sorry for the uninspired title for this post. i just spent the last hour reviewing these different sites and feel sooo
uncreative that this is as good as i get.
2riverthe landing page is way too cluttered, with a completely balanced, three-column format it lacks any visual hierarchy of the site. the only clue to where the current issue is by the blue header that you see only after your eye settles on the clean white space around the (useless) quote in the top center of the page.
but, once you delve into the issue, settle on a story, choose an writer and
then get to the actual piece, i love how it's laid out. it's like peeling back the husk from an ear of corn to get to the actual artwork on this site and we all know how much shucking corn sucks.
the use of audio and podcasts are a great (and unique) feature for this site. brevitynice color scheme and logo happening when you land on this page, although the large graphic of the marcel duchamp bike on the right sidebar drew my attention before the articles in the center. but you knew you were entering into friendly territory.
one thing that was really cool was the small intro into the work on the landing page with an icon that later became a large relevant graphic on the actual page. this
icon as a bullet really drew my interest to an article and then hooked me with the use of a teaser to the article. the subpages with the creative work were neatly laid out but if they decreased the font size you could eliminate the need to scroll sooo far down the page.
summerset reviewoooh, very artsy. yup, it was this site that zapped my mojo. i know we're not supposed to like landing pages that make you click to enter a site, but hell, i go anywhere that graphic led me. yep, i am a design slut, if you have a well-designed package, i'll do (just about) anything.
lilywhat the hell is this? first thing i thought of was
lily's a witch! full-moon, bare tree branches, mysterious female eyes peering back.
after scrolling to what seemed forever did i figure out what the hell this site was selling. and it wasn't worth buying -- blecchhh!
goddess help you if you stumble into the site -- you are literally trapped once you venture onto an article or photo piece. you can only move to the "next" item -- there is no escaping from lily's clutches.
mwah-ha-ha!everything was sized wayyy too big on this site. maybe a worthwhile place for wiccans (and i'm not picking on witches here) with no sense of 2-D design but i'm not trekking back to see what spell she cooked up this month.
philadelphia storiesnice place to land. everything made sense. noticed that just about every site so far has taken advantage of a white crisp, borderless background (except the freak lily).
what confused me was what was happening once you clicked on story or poetry. why two columns of links and the larger groups of links scrolling off and down the right side of the page? someother way of delineating featured content versus additional content was needed. unless of course i'm missing the boat entirely in which case, others may as well. once settled on a piece, though it was pretty easy to move about the site.
ahem, and i will now eat a big piece of humble pie as i finish coding my site.